destroy phoenix enforcer rulings

Fusion Destiny's weaker restrictions makes Destroy Phoenix Enforcer more accessible. A: Even if your hand is revealed, you can show your opponent the card you drew during your Draw Phase and activate the effect of Destiny HERO Dasher. A: If you apply the effect of War Rock Mountain, War Rock Fortia is not destroyed by battle, so you can activate its effect after damage calculation. Support YGOrganization on our Patreon to remove ads! In that spirit, I enjoy- Soulsbornes, tabletop gaming (Warhammer 40K), Fighting games, and Character Action games. + Portuguese name Fnix Executor, o HERI do Elemento + Primary type Fusion Monster + and Effect Monster + Romaji name Erementaru Hr Fenikkusugai + Ruby Japanese name EHERO + In this case, you can first activate the Spell Speed 1 effect of Floowandereeze and the Magnificent Map as Chain Link 2. " is not treated as an effect. Twitter: @wamiruladlan, 2016 - 2022 Digital Braves Media Group Sdn Bhd, Microsoft Windows, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Steam, Xbox One, Xbox Series X|S. If El Shaddoll Apkallone is in face-down Defense Position when its effect resolves, will its effect be applied? 7 New Cards: Cosmic Quasar & Crimson Dragon. Dragoon carries the benefit of ending games quickly due to his higher attack and burn damage removal. Like us? OCG 2021.07 Metagame Report #7 | Road of the King However, the OCG does not have a legal Red-Eyes Dark Dragoon. In layman's terms, Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer is a powerful board removal tool- it can remove itself from the board along with one other card, which is a good way to remove any problem cards on the board. DPE text states that If this card is destroyed by battle or card effect: You can activate this effect; Special Summon 1 "Destiny HERO" monster from your GY during the Standby Phase of the next turn. Dark Magician Girl TCG Accessories are now Available! A: No, they cannot. April 2, 2015 Redshift. A: It will not be applied. In this situation, my opponent Normal Summons Armageddon Knight and activates its effect. Already a patron? If this card is destroyed by battle or card effect: You can activate this . But when the effect of Destiny HERO Destroy Phoenix Enforcer is activated, you can chain Solemn Warning or Solemn Strike and negate the activation of the effect. This website is not produced by, endorsed by, supported by, or affiliated with 4k Media or Konami Digital Entertainment. I know that if I summon a monster from the extra deck using cyber-stein or waking the dragon that I can't summon that monster back to field using monster reborn because he wasn't summoned by fusion. Q: My opponent activates the effect of Unchained Soul of Disaster, targeting a Sky Striker Ace Link Monster I control, and using both monsters to Link Summon Unchained Soul of Rage. There are lots of useful resources linked around Yugioh101, check them out! PLayer B Activates Nibiru PLayer A activates DPE to pop itself and anaconda. Can I activate New Clear World targeting the Epigonos Token? Q: Inspector Boarder, a Synchro Monster, and an Xyz Monster are all on the field, and each player can activate monster effects . Q: I control a Magical Meltdown, and its effect that prevents my opponent from activating card effects when I Fusion Summon a monster is applying. A: If The Ultimate Creature of Destruction is Set on your field when resolving the effect of True Light, you can still Set another copy of The Ultimate Creature of Destruction. Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer Ruling I know that DPE activates after he's destroyed but does he activate once again in the next standbyphase or once we get to that phase he just summons and no one can respond or chain cards until he summons a hero? For more information, please see our Q: The effect of DNA Surgery that was activated by declaring Machine-Type is applying. Community content is available under. In this situation, if I activate the effect of True Light that Sets a Spell/Trap from my Deck, can I Set another copy of The Ultimate Creature of Destruction? Both fusion packages are amazing, and the TCG is unique for being able to play either one in the same format. You can only use each of the following effects of "Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer" once per turn. YuGiOh fans have been in a stir, after Mays banlist hinted at something a lot of fans were equal parts excited and afraid for- the coming of Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer in YuGiOh Master Duel. You can only use each of the following effects of "Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer" once per turn. Q: If I activate the second effect of Virtual World Gate Chuche targeting my Level 3 Virtual World Mai-Hime Lulu, can I choose to lower its Level? Being untargetable, indestructible, having the ability to destroy monsters and inflict burn without targeting, as well as omni-negation accompanied with an ATK boost is far superior to DPE's abilities. 111 listings on TCGplayer for Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer - YuGiOh - 1 Level 6 or higher "HERO" monster + 1 "Destiny HERO" monster <br>Monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK for each "HERO" card in your GY. In that case, will the effect of Destiny HERO Dasher be applied? A: No, you cannot. In this situation, if I activate Icejade Depths Inion Cradle, can my opponent chain the third effect of Swordsoul Catastrophe Qixing Longyuan? Dragoon offers power and fast wins, but with the price of bricks. I am playing a lair of darkness deck with cyber-stein and waking the dragon along with DPE in the extra deck. Support YGOrganization on our Patreon to remove ads! Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer Ruling : Yugioh101 - reddit Q: The Ultimate Creature of Destruction was Set to my field by its own effect. As a result, if I cannot Special Summon an Adventurer Token by the effect of Rite of Aramesia, can I still place Journey of Destiny from my Deck face-up in my Spell & Trap Zone? THIS IS SO SATISFYING!! By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Reiterating Edo Phoenix is a HERO Duelist who uses cards with tricky and difficult effects. A: It becomes Machine-Type. Fandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. These cards offer extension as a Pot of Greed, a free Special Summon, or both. Worse still, regardless of whose turn it is, it simply comes back the next standby phase, where it can do so again. Press J to jump to the feed. Afterward, can I activate the effect of Sky Striker Ace Raye in my Graveyard? If you successfully Special Summon an Adventurer Token with the effect of Rite of Aramesia and do not control Journey of Destiny, you can then place a Journey of Destiny from your Deck face-up in your Spell & Trap Zone. It should be noted that Celestial is the more important of the pair thanks to its graveyard effects- you can also substitute Dasher for Destiny HERO Plasma if you so desired. Nice". Destroy Phoenix Enforcer Ruling Scenario: Player A activates Predaplant verte anaconda to summon DPE. Already a patron? Destiny HERO- The Shining Phoenix Enforcer by NoahGArt. A: If Destiny HERO Dasher is not in your Graveyard when its effect resolves, the effect of Special Summoning is not applied. (Quick Effect): You can destroy both 1 card you control and 1 card on the field. The effect of Unchained Soul of Disaster performs a Link Summon using itself and the targeted monster as a material. If you activate the Set copy of The Ultimate Creature of Destruction by chaining to the effect of True Light, that copy will be face-up on your field when resolving the effect of True Light. If I activate the effect of Ignis Heat, the True Dracowarrior, can I activate a True Draco Continuous Spell with its effect? Rather than try to draw Fusion Destiny, Verte Anaconda can simply mimic its effect- paying an LP cost and then changing its effect to that card ability.The fact that its cost is simply two nondescript effect monsters makes it work with any deck. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. After El Shaddoll Construct is Fusion Summoned at Chain Link 2, the Chain Link 1 effect resolves, so after the Chain finishes resolving, it is no longer "when a monster is Fusion Summoned". Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. It can use its effect, it just can't bring itself back because it wasn't properly summoned, so if you activated the effect, then DPE would have to summon another Destiny HERO monster, if possible. I am aware that you can use its other effect to pop your opponents card and itself and then bring DPE back on the next turn. 45.14 Le migliori offerte per YuGiOh Playmat Destiny Hero Destroy Phoenix Enforcer TCG CCG Card Game Play Mat sono su Confronta prezzi e caratteristiche di prodotti nuovi e usati Molti articoli con consegna gratis Yes, it's just like Stardust Dragon using its effect after being summoned by Starlight Road. A: No, you cannot. Using this effect on your opponent's, If the card you select on your side of the field via this card's second effect is impervious to being destroyed, you will still be able to destroy the second card, as the destruction of the first card is not a condition for the destruction of the second. (Quick Effect): You can destroy both 1 card you control and 1 card on the field. End of Format Innovations: TCG DABL Metagame Report, TCG DABL Metagame Tournament Report: YCS Sydney 2023. If the OCG indicates anything, DPE will definitely impact the metagame. Open New Zealand is Now Live! [MERCHANDISE] Kaiba Corporation POP-UP Store, CDP: Blue-Eyes in 2023, featuring Ringowurm the Hundred Apple Dragon, [RD/LGP1] Goddess of Whimsy Tries Her Luck. A: In that case, the effects of Sacred Crane will not be negated while it is in face-down Defense Position, so its effect resolves normally. If you do, the turns will be skipped until the start of the Battle Phase of your next turn, but that Battle Phase will also be skipped. Full name Destiny HERO Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer, this fusion monster became a must-have pick in the physical card game thanks to its amazing effect as well as its near universal compatibility with any deck, since it required very few cards to break out and can do so with alarming consistency with the right build. However, when destroying itself for the second time, can DPE be special summoned again? Registration for the Yu-Gi-Oh! The Insanity of YCS Sydney: TCG DABL Metagame Report, Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer. Open New Zealand is Now Live! Official rulings posted on 04/02/15. A: If the activation of Rite of Aramesia is negated, you can activate the effects of monsters other than Special Summoned monsters during the same turn. However, it is possible to play Destroy Phoenix Enforcer if the player activates Destiny Fusion before Bearbrumm. Also, the "bricks" outclass Dark Magician and Red-Eyes Black Dragon. OCG Rulings " Must be Fusion Summoned and cannot be Special Summoned by other ways. Q: While the only monster I control is a War Rock Fortia, when that War Rock Fortia would be destroyed by battle, I apply the effect of War Rock Mountain and send it to the Graveyard instead. I've crafted Mekk-knight Crusadia Avramax,Destiny Hero-Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer,Baronne de Fleur,Predaplant Verte Anaconda,Knightmare Phoenix,Knightmare Unicorn,Underworld Goddess of the Closed World,Accesscode Talker,and Apollousa,Bow of the Goddess, [US - CA] [H] Paypal GS [W] EHero Phoenix Enforcer, Skyscraper 1 and 2, EHero Bubbleman Secret, Buster Blader, Yu-Gi-Oh! Deve ser Invocado por Invocao-Fuso e no pode ser Invocado por Invocao-Especial de nenhuma outra forma. On the other hand, DPE is slightly weaker, but offers incredible utility via his effects and fusion materials. If Sacred Crane is in face-down Defense Position when its effect resolves, will its effect be applied? Elemental HERO Phoenix Enforcer | Yu-Gi-Oh! Wiki | Fandom Source. https://yugipedia.com/wiki/Destiny_HERO_-_Destroy_Phoenix_Enforcerhttps://yugipedia.com/wiki/Token_CollectorPatreon: https://patreon.com/dpygoDiscord server:. You can only use each of the following effects of "Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer" once per turn. Also a proud UWE graduate with a degree in Media and Journalism, along with a TOA Diploma in Digital Animation. Q: If a Swordsoul Token Special Summoned by the effect of Swordsoul Blackout is equipped to a monster as an Equip Card, can I Special Summon monsters from the Extra Deck other than Synchro Monsters? In this case, when I activate the effect of El Shaddoll Construct, can the effect of Tri-Brigade Shuraig the Ominous Omen be chained to it? Q: I activated Mischief of the Time Goddess while I had 7 or more cards in my hand. Destroy Phoenix Enforcer Package : r/Yugioh101 - reddit SoulSurvival 10 mo. The monster becomes Machine-Type due to the effect of DNA Surgery after the effect of Vampire Sucker is applied. The weaker restriction on Fusion Destiny allows this engine to be live, and Tri-Brigade Ferrijit the Barren Blossom is able return engine bricks to the deck. Its like how stardust dragon summoned with starlight road cannot be special summoned from grave because it was not properly synchro summoned. Would DPE special summoned from the grave by its own effect still be counted as a fusion summoned monster or a special summoned monster? Event Announced! SwordSoul + Phoenix Enforcer? Verte Anaconda is still there to help! A: Even in this case, the effect of Ignis Heat, the True Dracowarrior can be activated. A small Database update just before Battle of Chaos drops. However, if the effect of Pot of Prosperity is negated, you cannot draw cards with card effects during the same turn. Check me out on Twitch: https://www.twitch.tv/distantcoder Join my Discord Server: https://discord.gg/rc0 If you wish to support me further, here is a link to my Patreon where you can earn special supporter benefits: https://www.patreon.com/DistantCoder VISIT CARDBRAWLERS AT https://cardbrawlers.com/?ref=Distant ! Card Gallery:Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer This is a welcoming community where players make posts to ask for any help they would like. destiny hero destroyer phoenix enforcer for sale | eBay Q: While the effect of Shadow-Imprisoning Mirror is applying, El Shaddoll Apkallone is Special Summoned and its effect is activated. 136 listings on TCGplayer for Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer - YuGiOh - 1 Level 6 or higher "HERO" monster + 1 "Destiny HERO" monster <br>Monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK for each "HERO" card in your GY. When you activate Icejade Depths Inion Cradle to the Field Zone, it is treated as a card on the field, and the effect of Icejade Empress Cosmocroix will be applied. In this situation, I Special Summon monsters multiple times by effects activated on the same Chain. Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer - 2022 Tin of the Pharaoh's Source However, if you draw a monster at a timing that is not the last thing to happen in a Chain, such as when you draw a monster by an effect that was activated as Chain Link 2 or higher, you cannot activate the effect of Destiny HERO Dasher. It can also come down to player preference. Q: If the effect of Destiny HERO Destroy Phoenix Enforcer was activated, can the Special Summon performed by that effect be negated by Solemn Judgment or Solemn Strike? Monster effects activated while the effects of Inspector Boarder are negated still count toward the number of monster effects activated while Inspector Boarder is in the Monster Zone. After El Shaddoll Construct is Fusion Summoned at Chain Link 2, the Chain Link 1 effect resolves, so after the Chain finishes resolving, it is no longer when a monster is Fusion Summoned. Registration for 250th YCS in London is Now Open! These engine pieces provide more value than the wizard and dragon while summoning a boss monster. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. It's a slow search To stay in the know, [USA-CA] [H] PSA 8 1st Ed UTR Elemental Hero Phoenix Enforcer, TT Thrust, Purrely, Binder [W] List. Master Duel | Episode 6 "Underworld Deck and Phoenix Enforcer" | Season 1: Fusion Heroes, doest opponent have to say what they are targeting example phoenix enforcer effect my opponent say he is targeting, When you summon Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer. Don't forget to use promo code CODER10 for 10% discount on all your orders !Check out EwinRACING at the following link and be sure to use promo code \"coder20\" for 20% off your purchase! Yu-Gi-Oh! However, due to the effect of your opponents Great Shogun Shien, you cannot activate any more Spells/Traps, so when you resolve the effect of Ignis Heat, the True Dracowarrior, you cannot activate a True Draco Continuous Spell. Optional, if you want to hear back from us regarding this bug. There are lots of useful resources linked around Yugioh101, check them out! Q: I control an Icejade Empress Cosmocroix, and my opponent controls a Swordsoul Catastrophe Qixing Longyuan that was Special Summoned during the previous turn. What I wanted: Phoenix Enforcer. If Tri-Brigade Revolt is already drawn, Tri-Brigade can also Link into Verte. If the Adventurer Token cannot be Special Summoned, you cannot place Journey of Destiny onto the field. Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer - Burst of Destiny - YuGiOh - TCGplayer YGOPRODeck Cup - Master Circuit Sign-ups! A: No, you do not. Also, if the effect of my Pot of Prosperity is negated by the effect of Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring, can I draw cards with card effects this turn? Destiny Hero: Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer ruling : r/Yugioh101 - reddit Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer, This card's effect is especially useful if it destroys itself alongside the other card, as you can simply summon it from the Graveyard on your next turn. My Rebawoo in Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer colors. In that case, can I activate the effect of Mist Valley Apex Avian as Chain Link 2, and the effect of Floowandereeze and the Magnificent Map as Chain Link 3? Unless a footnote linking directly to KONAMI's own Database is directly tied to a remark we make, treat it solely as the opinion of The Organization. 3 Deadly Decks With Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer Its Quick Effect destroys a card you control, as well as any card on the field, potentially interrupting your opponent's plays. Destiny Hero - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer. Q: Inspector Boarder, a Synchro Monster, and an Xyz Monster are all on the field, and each player can activate monster effects up to twice each turn. A: In that case, you cannot choose a total of 2 cards to be destroyed, so no effect is applied. If I skip turns until the start of the Battle Phase of my next turn, do I discard for the hand size limit so that the number of cards in my hand becomes 6? Help new and returning players join Yugioh! When the Chain resolves, I first Fusion Summon El Shaddoll Construct, then my opponent Link Summons Tri-Brigade Shuraig the Ominous Omen. $59.65. Privacy Policy. YuGiOh Playmat Destiny Hero Destroy Phoenix Enforcer TCG CCG Card Game Support YGOrganization on Patreon to remove ads and get early info! Q: While the effect of Lose 1 Turn is applying, Sacred Crane is Special Summoned and its effect is activated. Registration for the Yu-Gi-Oh! The Pot Collection is Now Available for Pre-Order! If so, what happens to the next Battle Phase? 1 Level 6 or higher "HERO" monster + 1 "Destiny HERO" monster. Monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK for each HERO card in your GY. When this effect is applied to a Level 3 or lower monster, you must increase its Level by 3. Q: My hand is revealed due to the effect of Respect Play. A: Even in this case, its effect is negated. In laymans terms, Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer is a powerful board removal tool- it can remove itself from the board along with one other card, which is a good way to remove any problem cards on the board. If so, can I activate a third monster effect this turn? That being said, every archetype is sure to have its tools to make the materials for Verte Anaconda. Multiple options exist for DPE's fusion materials, but the most common ones are Destiny Hero - Celestial and Destiny Hero - Dasher. You can only use each of the following effects of "Destiny HERO - Destroy Phoenix Enforcer" once per turn. Duel at the highest level against Duelists all over the world. Card Rulings:Elemental HERO Phoenix Enforcer - Yu-Gi-Oh! Wiki Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcerhas a Continuous Effect that lowers all of your opponent's monsters by 200 ATK for each HERO card you have in your Graveyard. Both packages are viable, but there is one interaction Drytron players must be wary of for DPE. For example, Tri-Brigade never plays the Dragoon package because it conflicts with Tri-Brigade Bearbrumm the Rampant Rampager. Square Enix President Yosuke Matsuda To Be Replaced By Takashi Kiryu, The Rarest 3DS Games To Get Before The eShop Closes Down, PlayStation Celebrates Live From PS5 Campaign with Special Public Installation. (Make sure you are already logged into Patreon before logging in here). ago. Therefore, you will be in your End Phase. Monsters your opponent controls lose 200 ATK for each "HERO" card in your GY. Number VI of The Organization, Redshift is a firm believer that the toilet paper should be pulled outward from the top of the roll, not the bottom. phoenix enforcer - Reddit post and comment search - SocialGrep Q: I control an Epigonos Token Special Summoned by the effect of Epigonen the Imitarian. Card Tips:Destiny HERO - Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer Unless a footnote linking directly to KONAMI's own Database is directly tied to a remark we make, treat it solely as the opinion of The Organization. The pros of Dragoon outweigh the risks, but those bricks are unforgiving. Search Reddit posts and comments - see average sentiment, top terms, activity per day and more Cookie Notice Q: I activate the effect of a Destiny HERO Dasher in my Graveyard that Special Summons a monster from my hand, but the activation is negated due to an effect chained by my opponent. During my turn, my opponent activates Tri-Brigade Revolt as Chain Link 1, and I chain the effect of Shaddoll Schism as Chain Link 2. The existence of both fusions creates a debate on which fusion will be superior for the TCG. Master Duel Invitational Features Prominent Content Creators. from Germany. Yes, it's just like Stardust Dragon using its effect after being summoned by Starlight Road. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. +$8.40 shipping. #InhumanInnsport Felicity Phoenix, harpy enforcer of the local mob. Picking Your Boss Fusion: Dragoon or Enforcer? - YGOPRODeck What happens if I do not control any cards when the effect resolves? A: No, you cannot. " effect is a Continuous Effect. Worse still, regardless of whose turn it is, it simply comes back the next standby phase, where it can do so again. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer, Floowandereeze & Swordsoul Rulings | Know This is a welcoming community where players make posts to ask for any help they would like. Assuming you mean phantom knights by pk, it may be worth playing more than 40 cards to minimize your chances of drawing bricks. Q: If the activation of my Rite of Aramesia is negated by the effect of Borreload Savage Dragon, can I activate the effects of monsters other than Special Summoned monsters this turn? A: In that case, regardless of the number of Special Summons, the effect of Performapal Sword Fish is only activated once after the Chain resolves. Yu-Gi-Oh! The Judges' Lounge | Destroy Phoenix Enforcer Ruling Megatin 2022 Promo Poster - Ultra Diviner, Destroyer Phoenix Enforcer, Thunder Armed Dragon, Prismatic Secret Branded Opening. You can activate it even if your Life Points are 10 or less. The literal and graphical information presented on this site about Yu-Gi-Oh!, including card images, the attribute, level/rank and type symbols, and card text, is copyright 4K Media Inc, a subsidiary of Konami Digital Entertainment, Inc. Leveling Up for Limited Formats #1: The Basics of Limited, TCG Meta Snapshot: Kashtira February 2023, The Design of Yu-Gi-Oh 1: Built for Spectacle, 2 New Cards: Elemental HERO & Code Talker. This website is not produced by, endorsed by, supported by, or affiliated with 4k Media or Konami Digital Entertainment. A: An Epigonos Token does not have an original Type or Attribute, so regardless of what Type and Attribute the Epigonos Token has on the field, New Clear World cannot target an Epigonos Token. can proxy f magician summon dark Phoenix enforcer??? Dragoon may be the better option without the interaction and his ability to end the game faster. *Disclosure: Some of the links above are affiliate links, meaning, at no additional cost to you, Fandom will earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. Are they a good match? They end up meaning the same thing as shown above, but it also explains why this question would need to be asked, and why the answer is worded the way it is. Therefore, you cannot Set another copy of The Ultimate Creature of Destruction with the effect of True Light. A note to readers: In Japanese text, the effects of Swordsoul cards that restrict you from Special Summoning are worded as While there are Tokens Special Summoned by this effect, instead of what we see in English, While that Token is in the Monster Zone,. Of course, Dragoon is usually cheesed with Predaplant Verte Anaconda, but it doesn't change the fact that two and a half bricks are commited to the deck. In addition, Sky Striker prefers DPE over Dragoon. Q: If Vanity's Emptiness is chained to Mask Change or Mask Change II, how do they resolve? Gyaguna () went 7-0 and finished 1st in "39th Next Play Cup" which had 32 participants. Requiring two vanillas and a spell that may determine your only play is the sacrifice for a powerful monster. Event Announced!

Brigham And Women's Foxborough Lab Hours, 5 Letter Words With U And E In Them, Sun Conjunct Jupiter Synastry, Articles D
This entry was posted in youngstown state football roster 1990. Bookmark the university of maryland hospital psychiatric unit.

destroy phoenix enforcer rulings